|
Post by Nonfatman on Feb 16, 2012 10:57:41 GMT -5
What's all the posts about Pink Floyd? Is Roger Waters dead or something? Why not start the Pink Floyd board or something like that. May you constantly amaze us. Well, as you know, Earl, people are allowed to post freely here, on any topic they like, including other bands. Having said that, I can't stand Pink Floyd. I find most of their music depressing, monotonous and dull, and their lyrics pretty much confined to the same topics of anti-authoritarianism over and over again. Tull is just so infinitely better.....and so much more fun! Jeff
|
|
|
Post by jtul07 on Feb 16, 2012 10:59:37 GMT -5
Jim, lovest thou the Floyd, more than Tull? That one day falls one day too soon. ;D ;D ;D ;D TULL - VOLUTION ;D ;D ;D ;D
|
|
|
Post by My God on Feb 16, 2012 11:08:02 GMT -5
Jim, lovest thou the Floyd, more than Tull? That one day falls one day too soon. ;D TULL - VOLUTION ;D Now that's better, Jim. Warchild, dance the days, and the nights away.
|
|
|
Post by My God on Feb 16, 2012 11:28:16 GMT -5
What's all the posts about Pink Floyd? Is Roger Waters dead or something? Why not start the Pink Floyd board or something like that. May you constantly amaze us. Well, as you know, Earl, people are allowed to post freely here, on any topic they like, including other bands. Having said that, I can't stand Pink Floyd. I find most of their music depressing, monotonous and dull, and their lyrics pretty much confined to the same topics of anti-authoritarianism over and over again. Tull is just so infinitely better.....and so much more fun! Jeff I had some Pink Floyd records in the 70's. But I soon got irrepressively Bored! Thanks. Oh, by the way, which one's Pink?
|
|
|
Post by jtul07 on Feb 16, 2012 11:40:42 GMT -5
Pink Floyd is a unique type of music which appeals to certain mood or mindset. If you wonder about my loyalty to Tull, I have never spent a dime on a Pink Floyd concert. Roger Waters is touring this summer yet I am saving my cash for TAAB 2 and Martin's New Day. If I enjoy their videos and music, it usually happens much less than my Tull moments. Other than Tull, I do collect more Pink Floyd artwork as well. The artist Storm Thorgerson is incredible. When I go camping, Pink Floyd is a real highlight of my experience. The woods come alive at night! Also, "Divinities" is right there with me.
|
|
|
Post by Nonfatman on Feb 16, 2012 11:54:33 GMT -5
Pink Floyd is a unique type of music which appeals to certain mood or mindset. If you wonder about my loyalty to Tull, I have never spent a dime on a Pink Floyd concert. Roger Waters is touring this summer yet I am saving my cash for TAAB 2 and Martin's New Day. If I enjoy their videos and music, it usually happens much less than my Tull moments. Other than Tull, I do collect more Pink Floyd artwork as well. The artist Storm Thorgerson is incredible. When I go camping, Pink Floyd is a real highlight of my experience. The woods come alive at night! Also, "Divinities" is right there with me. No doubts whatsoever about your loyalty to Tull, Jim! You prove that here each and every day, and have been the most prolific poster on the board over the past seven or eight months since you joined us. You've got a lot of supporters here in liking Pink Floyd. I know Pat, Greg and JohnN, like them a whole lot. I like some of what they do....the more guitar-oriented albums like Animals, for instance. Music and lyrics are a very personal thing. What appeals to one person does nothing for someone else. The lyrics to Dark Side of the Moon are great, no question, but I never really connected with Pink Floyd. I don't find the same kind of variety or sense of humor and fun that I do with Tull. (No band is more fun than Tull....just look at the new Brick, complete with the online St. Cleve's Chronicle...who else does anything like that?) Although you like Floyd more than I do, I know you essentially agree with me. It's interesting to share opinions. That's why we're here. Jeff
|
|
|
Post by jtul07 on Feb 16, 2012 12:55:55 GMT -5
No doubts whatsoever about your loyalty to Tull, Jim! You prove that here each and every day, and have been the most prolific poster on the board over the past seven or eight months since you joined us. Jeff Thanks Jeff, ;D Would you be my Valentine? ;D
|
|
Rrrrrrrray
One of the Youngest of the Family
Posts: 91
|
Post by Rrrrrrrray on Feb 16, 2012 17:22:04 GMT -5
Certainly a fan of the 67-77 version of Pink Floyd, afraid the Wall and its attendant movie, which just might be the worst in any genre I have ever seen, challenged by Zep's 76 movie, apexing with one of them, I think Robert Plant, on a mighty white steed, nearly wretched. Entirely possible, though not likely, that there could be elements of Division Bell I would like, never gave it a try. I did hear of Roger Waters admonishing a crowd for smoking marijuana. Wonder if it ever crossed his mind that without marijuana, he and all members of Pink Floyd would have been working a regular job for decades now. Not saying you have to be stoned to appreciate, saying it had everything to do with their getting on the map in the first place. I do recall his Sister saying at no point was her brother insane, which I would find entirely believable, having learned long ago to take the certainty with which people talk of strangers with a massive grain of salt, particularly where celebrity is concerned. And the line concerning him of "You wore out your welcome with random precision" will always have personal resonance.
|
|
|
Post by jtul07 on Feb 16, 2012 17:27:55 GMT -5
Certainly a fan of the 67-77 version of Pink Floyd, afraid the Wall and its attendant movie, which just might be the worst in any genre I have ever seen, challenged by Zep's 76 movie, apexing with one of them, I think Robert Plant, on a mighty white steed, nearly wretched. Entirely possible, though not likely, that there could be elements of Division Bell I would like, never gave it a try. I did hear of Roger Waters admonishing a crowd for smoking marijuana. Wonder if it ever crossed his mind that without marijuana, he and all members of Pink Floyd would have been working a regular job for decades now. Not saying you have to be stoned to appreciate, saying it had everything to do with their getting on the map in the first place. I do recall his Sister saying at no point was her brother insane, which I would find entirely believable, having learned long ago to take the certainty with which people talk of strangers with a massive grain of salt, particularly where celebrity is concerned. And the line concerning him of "You wore out your welcome with random precision" will always have personal resonance. Interesting points about Roger Waters. Sounds a little like Ian whining about his audience having too much fun. Do people complain more when they get older?
|
|
Rrrrrrrray
One of the Youngest of the Family
Posts: 91
|
Post by Rrrrrrrray on Feb 16, 2012 21:08:52 GMT -5
Certainly a fan of the 67-77 version of Pink Floyd, afraid the Wall and its attendant movie, which just might be the worst in any genre I have ever seen, challenged by Zep's 76 movie, apexing with one of them, I think Robert Plant, on a mighty white steed, nearly wretched. Entirely possible, though not likely, that there could be elements of Division Bell I would like, never gave it a try. I did hear of Roger Waters admonishing a crowd for smoking marijuana. Wonder if it ever crossed his mind that without marijuana, he and all members of Pink Floyd would have been working a regular job for decades now. Not saying you have to be stoned to appreciate, saying it had everything to do with their getting on the map in the first place. I do recall his Sister saying at no point was her brother insane, which I would find entirely believable, having learned long ago to take the certainty with which people talk of strangers with a massive grain of salt, particularly where celebrity is concerned. And the line concerning him of "You wore out your welcome with random precision" will always have personal resonance. Interesting points about Roger Waters. Sounds a little like Ian whining about his audience having too much fun. Do people complain more when they get older? Pretty sure not, but since I have only just crossed that precipice, let me get back to you. Glad you could understand what I wrote, because I notice in the second paragraph I rambled right into talking about Syd Barrett without actually saying him by name. I have a way of doing that.
|
|
|
Post by Morthoron on Feb 16, 2012 21:57:07 GMT -5
Pink Floyd is a unique type of music which appeals to certain mood or mindset. If you wonder about my loyalty to Tull, I have never spent a dime on a Pink Floyd concert. Roger Waters is touring this summer yet I am saving my cash for TAAB 2 and Martin's New Day. If I enjoy their videos and music, it usually happens much less than my Tull moments. Other than Tull, I do collect more Pink Floyd artwork as well. The artist Storm Thorgerson is incredible. When I go camping, Pink Floyd is a real highlight of my experience. The woods come alive at night! Also, "Divinities" is right there with me. No doubts whatsoever about your loyalty to Tull, Jim! You prove that here each and every day, and have been the most prolific poster on the board over the past seven or eight months since you joined us. You've got a lot of supporters here in liking Pink Floyd. I know Pat, Greg and JohnN, like them a whole lot. I like some of what they do....the more guitar-oriented albums like Animals, for instance. Music and lyrics are a very personal thing. What appeals to one person does nothing for someone else. The lyrics to Dark Side of the Moon are great, no question, but I never really connected with Pink Floyd. I don't find the same kind of variety or sense of humor and fun that I do with Tull. (No band is more fun than Tull....just look at the new Brick, complete with the online St. Cleve's Chronicle...who else does anything like that?) Although you like Floyd more than I do, I know you essentially agree with me. It's interesting to share opinions. That's why we're here. Jeff "This is supposed to be a happy occasion! Let's not bicker and argue over who killed who." I have quite a wide range as far as musical tastes, but both bands are integral to my lifelong listening experience. So I can't bloody well put Tull on a pedestal and eschew Floyd. I've seen both bands in concert multiple times, and although I cherish each and every tour I've seen, I will certainly have to give the nod to Floyd as far as the overall concert experience. They were astounding -- even the times I saw them without several hits of acid. *stares blankly* Ummm...what were we talking about again? *blinks* And are you gonna eat that donut?
|
|
|
Post by Nonfatman on Feb 16, 2012 22:40:14 GMT -5
Never heard Waters getting pissed about weed. Ian, on the other hand I have seen stop shows several times and threaten audience members who were tokin a doob. Waters would get pissed about noisy crowds and lighting of fireworks etc.. He didn't connect with fans at all and felt alienated by them. That was the concept behind the Wall stage show, to build a Wall between the band and the audience. There's a famous incident where he actually spit on a fan. I know alot of people who love Floyd more than most any band. On the other hand I know many who hate them and have walked out of the shows including 'Dark Side of the Moon'. I used to hate them until I was about 16 when a friend would play them constantly. I would dread when he would reach for the Floyd lp's. Then one day I had a dream (in slow motion) where I was walking down a long hallway with rows of lights while the guitar solo for "Comfortably Numb" played. I woke up and was a Floyd fan ever since. I have actually played and performed many entire Floyd albums live over the years so I don't listen to them much these days. To me it was all about the balance of dynamics between Waters and Gilmour. Waters is the big bummer then Gilmour is the uplifting one with the soothing voice and unmistakable beautiful guitar tone. Saw them in Toronto 94 and it was insane! Saw waters several times and I suggest you see the Wall concert this summer if you can. The production is mind boggling.. Best album by far is "Animals". I have tried over the years to like Pink Floyd, but I just have never been able to get into them, except I do like Animals and most of Dark Side. I bought The Final Cut, didn't like it. I bought The Division Bell and really hated it, thought it was incredibly boring. The problem for me is that I like Gilmour's guitar, but I hate the keyboards in Floyd. They're loud and annoying. I have never liked some of their biggest hits like Comfortably Numb, Welcome to the Machine or Another Brick in the Wall. Recently, Greg posted some videos here, songs I was not familiar with, and I listened to them. They were alright, but I came away with the same impression....just can't really get into them. Division Bell came out around the same time as Roots to Branches. I read a review that totally trashed it, and in so doing, compared it very disfavorably to RTB. I didn't know you had played entire Pink Floyd shows, Erin. Were you a member of a PF tribute band at one time? Jeff
|
|
|
Post by jtul07 on Feb 16, 2012 22:54:27 GMT -5
Pretty sure not, but since I have only just crossed that precipice, let me get back to you. Glad you could understand what I wrote, because I notice in the second paragraph I rambled right into talking about Syd Barrett without actually saying him by name. I have a way of doing that. Just to be clear, I wondered why Roger Waters and Ian Anderson would be so cranky. Being artistic is one thing, whining about your audience is the other. Pink Floyd became more enjoyable to me with David Gilmour in charge. His style and musicianship have evolved into some great albums. I even like his solo stuff more today, which at first was less satisfying. The thread which got started by Serge, was a nice idea for contrast of music taste. We all enjoy Tull more than Pink Floyd, but not to measure in terms of loyalty. I got a kick from an earlier post to show my true feelings. My Tull dedication is over 1000%, while I love Pink Floyd on special occasions too. Ian has a real charm and I love Martin as well. If Roger Waters and Ian Anderson were so upset with their fans, they should have retired years ago. I just hope they remember who pays for their tickets and begs for an autograph. Life is a long song, so keep a smile on your face or it won't last. ;D P.S. Did someone bring doughnuts? I love chocolate icing with cream inside.
|
|
|
Post by janu on Feb 17, 2012 1:42:31 GMT -5
When I started this thread off my only purpose was to share with all of you a special BBC documentary reviewing each Floyd's video-clips so far released, in no event provoking a fuss comparing bands. I'm a bit annoyed with one of the comments dumped here. He knows well whom I'm referin' to. Randomly I stumbled with this poster on the web . I consider myself a PF hard core fan, this is what I started this thread for. Although Tull is my ever favourite band, have to say it. Thanks Jim for having persevered on this thread.
|
|
|
Post by tootull on Feb 17, 2012 9:41:11 GMT -5
I really like Ian's brief input here. For those that care, this is a HDCD. Gone to join a Pink Floyd board...
|
|
|
Post by jtul07 on Feb 19, 2012 17:07:14 GMT -5
Back Against The Wall "The Thin Ice" .................Ian Anderson Vocals/Flute.............. "Is There Anybody Out There?"
|
|
|
Post by TM on Feb 19, 2012 20:53:06 GMT -5
Great vocals by Ian. But the credits credit Billy Sherwood?
|
|
|
Post by jtul07 on Feb 21, 2012 8:07:27 GMT -5
|
|
|
Post by jtul07 on Feb 23, 2012 9:23:25 GMT -5
[glow=black,6,300]David Gilmour[/glow]
|
|
|
Post by jtul07 on Feb 23, 2012 15:44:18 GMT -5
Fender 50th Anniversary
DAVID GILMOUR PLAYS "SORROW"................FENDER 50th R.I.P. RICHARD WRIGHT, SYD BARRETT
|
|
|
Post by Morthoron on Feb 23, 2012 22:00:53 GMT -5
Here are two songs from David Gilmour's first two solo albums, David Gilmour and About Face, two sadly underappreciated albums that have some of the best post-Wall material (from Floyd or Waters):
|
|
|
Post by jtul07 on Feb 24, 2012 7:58:02 GMT -5
Here are two songs from David Gilmour's first two solo albums, David Gilmour and About Face, two sadly underappreciated albums that have some of the best post-Wall material (from Floyd or Waters): I think that the fear of Pink Floyd being "Put On Ice" made it hard for David Gilmour. After "The Final Cut" in '82, it seemed as though Pink Floyd was over when Rick Wright left the band. Gilmour got on MTV with a new style, but needed Nick Mason and Rick Wright to give his image a boost. Roger was not happy about that was he? So he went to court over the name Pink Floyd. These songs are better with age like wine from the cellar.
|
|
Deleted
Deleted Member
Posts: 0
|
Post by Deleted on Feb 24, 2012 17:38:57 GMT -5
Wow thanks Tulltapes and Jim. I've never seen the other rendition of the pink floyd ladies!
|
|
|
Post by jtul07 on Mar 2, 2012 15:12:41 GMT -5
[glow=black,8,300]The Final Cut[/glow]
|
|
|
Post by Nonfatman on Mar 2, 2012 15:54:00 GMT -5
[glow=black,8,300]The Final Cut[/glow] The more I listen to Pink Floyd, the less I like them. I bought both The Final Cut and The Division Bell, and hated them both. I thought I liked Dark Side, until listening to it the other day in the car, once again trying to get into it. I just couldn't. Aside from Money and Time, I did not care for any of it. Us and Them I find to be immensely boring and sleep inducing, plus I hate the annoying female vocalist who keeps cropping up and all that inane yabbering and laughter. I really hated the album, and I will be donating it to a church thrift shop soon. This is their greatest classic? Let me tell you something, I listened to Walk Into Light right afterward, probably the closest Tull equivalent to Pink Floyd, yet middle of the pack in terms of Ian's best work, and it simply blew Dark Side of the Moon out of the water. Then, having remembered liking Animals at one time, I played that one too, straight through, with the same result...I hated it. For some reason it just came across as sounding rather juvenile, something I may have liked as a teenager, but have outgrown since then. So the thrift shop will be getting that one too. Both albums are cold, humorless, depressing, something to listen to if you're contemplating suicide. They really are a band without a soul, as far as I'm concerned. I just can't stand them. Jeff
|
|